Skip to content
The ContinuumPathway
Home For police How it works About Insights Contact

Career and work

Why Being Good at Your Job Does Not Stop You Doubting Yourself

Being good at your job earns other people's trust. It does not automatically settle your own. Self doubt at work despite success is common among capable people, because competence and confidence run on different evidence. This piece is for the person who gets promoted, praised and relied on, and still lies awake replaying the last decision.

There is more on confidence at work in the Insights section on work and careers.

Aimee Templeman, decision coach By Aimee Templeman 6 minute read
A stone cairn on a ridge above a misty valley, for self-doubt in capable people at work

The research, briefly

62Studies in a 2020 systematic review of imposter feelings
14,161People taking part across those studies
9 to 82%Reported prevalence, depending on the measure used
0Studies it found that tested a treatment, in searches to May 2018

Source: Bravata and colleagues, Journal of General Internal Medicine, 2020.

Competent and unsure at the same time

Competence and self-doubt are not opposites. Competence describes what you can do. Self-doubt concerns how reliably you recognise, interpret and trust that evidence. You can hold a strong record and still keep your attention fixed on the next possible mistake.

You can be promoted, respected in the room and trusted with difficult decisions while privately wondering whether you are about to be found out. A strong record may be visible to everyone else while your own eyes stay on what could go wrong.

It is more common than it feels from the inside. The 2020 review summarised in the figures pooled 62 studies and found imposter feelings in anywhere from 9 to 82 per cent of participants, among men and women alike, from teenagers to late-career professionals. The wide range tells you the measuring is rough. The pattern itself is real.

Promotion often turns the volume up. A new role brings a new learning curve, and a mind that runs on doubt reads ordinary learning as proof of inadequacy. Success gets credited to luck, timing or a generous boss. Mistakes get filed as evidence.

Why high performers feel it most

High performers often feel it most because their sense of value was built on being useful, and because capability hides strain. When approval followed performance for years, every limit starts to feel like a threat, and extra effort covers the cracks until it cannot.

This can be especially familiar to people praised early for achievement or usefulness. When approval repeatedly followed performance, it was easy to learn that being valuable meant being useful. The lesson may never have been spoken aloud, but it can still shape how much work feels like enough.

Burnout does not always look like collapse from the outside. Someone with considerable skill may compensate for depletion through more effort, tighter control and longer hours. Their capability can delay recognition of the problem because the work continues to get done.

That does not mean burnout is merely a cover for a confidence problem. The World Health Organisation describes it as an occupational phenomenon associated with chronic workplace stress that has not been successfully managed. Workload, culture, resourcing and control still matter.

Imposter feelings or over-functioning?

The term imposter syndrome is often used for persistent doubt despite evidence of competence. It may describe part of your experience, but it should not automatically place the whole problem inside your head. Sometimes expectations are unclear or the workload is excessive. Sometimes you have become used to carrying responsibilities that should be shared. That pattern is often called over-functioning: doing more than your fair or sustainable share to keep a system, relationship or team steady.

What helps

What closes the gap

The gap closes with accurate evidence, not another confidence speech. That means checking what your doubt is based on, counting the load you carry, and treating your limits as information rather than a verdict on your character.

Rest that has to be earned can become another transaction you are still performing.

  1. 1

    Ask two questions

    What evidence supports my doubt? What load am I carrying that would make almost anyone feel stretched? The answer may include internal beliefs, external conditions or both.

  2. 2

    Keep a plain record

    Write down decisions that worked, a sentence each, in the week they happen. Doubt edits memory after the fact. A note made at the time is harder to argue with.

  3. 3

    Learn your early signals

    Notice what happens before concentration drops, patience disappears or work begins taking far longer than it should.

  4. 4

    Treat one limit as information

    A finishing time, a workload conversation, a delegated task or an evening without checking messages. Choose one and keep it, rather than waiting to earn it.

Earning rest sounds responsible: finish enough, then stop. The difficulty is that enough keeps moving. Self-trust at work includes believing your own signals before your body or performance forces the issue.

Support that fits

The right support depends on what sits underneath the doubt. If it is mostly about how you work, decide and lead, career coaching fits. If it comes with anxiety, low mood or old hurt, a psychologist is the better first call.

In career coaching with me, we look at the actual evidence of your performance, the load you carry and the decisions your doubt keeps making for you, like turning down the next role or refusing to delegate. If the pattern runs wider than work, confidence and mindset coaching looks at the beliefs underneath it.

My own background is 30 years of leadership in policing, so the weight of senior roles is familiar ground. I will not hand you a pep talk. We will look at what is true.

Doubting a call you already made?

Bring the decision and the doubt. We will go through the evidence together.

Book a quick chat

Asked often

Doubt, promotion and help

Is this imposter syndrome?

Possibly, in part. Imposter syndrome describes persistent doubt despite evidence of competence, and it is common. It is not a formal diagnosis. Uncertainty can also reflect excessive workload, unclear expectations, discrimination, inadequate support or a real skill gap, so the right response depends on the cause.

Does it go away with promotion?

Usually not on its own. A bigger role brings a new learning curve, more visibility and higher stakes, which can turn self-doubt up rather than down. What helps is evidence you trust, fair expectations of yourself while you learn the role, and limits you keep. A title changes the stakes, not the habit.

Coach or therapist?

If the doubt sits mainly in how you work, decide and lead, a coach is a reasonable fit. If it comes with persistent anxiety, low mood, panic or memories of past harm, start with a GP or psychologist. Some people use both, with each practitioner aware of the other.

Portrait of Aimee Templeman
About the authorAimee Templeman is the founder of The Continuum Pathway. She has spent 30 years in policing, has led large teams, and has studied psychology and law. She coaches police officers who are good at holding everything together and want to work out what's next for the person underneath the uniform.

Worth reading next

The Continuum Pathway provides coaching. It isn't counselling, psychology or a crisis service. If you need urgent support, call 000 or Lifeline on 13 11 14.