Skip to content
The ContinuumPathway
Home For police How it works About Insights Contact

Career and work

Is a Career Coach Worth It? How to Decide

Is a career coach worth it? Yes, when you are stuck on a real decision about your work and talking to friends has stopped helping. No, when what you need is a job lead, a sharper resume or treatment for stress. The difference comes down to the problem you are paying to solve.

This guide is for anyone weighing the cost before booking. Related pieces sit in the Insights collection on careers.

Aimee Templeman, decision coach By Aimee Templeman 6 minute read
A flat sandstone step at the edge of still water with the next stone just ahead, for deciding whether a career coach is worth it

When career coaching pays off

Career coaching pays off when there is a decision on the table and you keep circling it: stay or go, step up or step back, retrain or reshape the role. A coach earns the fee by shortening months of indecision into weeks of structured thinking.

The return is rarely a pay rise you can point to. It is the cost you avoid. A rushed resignation, a promotion you did not want, two years of study toward work you have never tried. Each of those costs far more than a few sessions.

It also pays off when the people around you have a stake in the answer. Your partner worries about the mortgage. Your manager wants you to stay. A friend thinks you should have left years ago. A coach has no stake in which way you go, which is harder to find than it sounds.

Likely worth it if

  • The same work question has followed you for six months or more.
  • Everyone you could ask has an interest in your answer.
  • A wrong move would cost real money or years.
  • You are willing to do work between sessions.

Probably not yet if

  • You have chosen the role and need applications.
  • You are not sleeping or coping day to day.
  • You want someone else to make the call.

When it does not

Career coaching is poor value when the problem is not a decision. If you already know the role you want, a resume writer or recruiter will help more. If stress is affecting your health, a GP or psychologist comes first. Coaching cannot fix either.

The common complaint about coaches is generic advice: tidy up your LinkedIn, network more, find your passion. You could read that for free. That usually happens when nobody named the actual question at the start, so the sessions drift.

It also disappoints people who hope a coach will tell them what to do. A good coach asks harder questions than you would ask yourself and holds you to the answers, but the choice stays yours. If you want a recommendation handed over, you will feel short-changed.

Timing matters too. Deep in burnout or a crisis at home is not the moment for a big career call. Steady yourself first.

Real numbers only

What it costs

There is no official price list for coaching in Australia. The International Coaching Federation's 2023 study found the average one-hour session in Oceania cost US$259 in 2022. Fixed programs are easier to judge than hourly rates, because you can see the total upfront.

US$259Average one-hour session fee in Oceania, 2022
US$244Global average in the same study
$1,000My program: four sessions over eight weeks
$250Or four fortnightly payments, with the rest refunded if the first session isn't right

Source for the averages: ICF Global Coaching Study 2023, executive summary.

Those averages include executive coaching paid for by employers, which the same study links to higher fees, so private clients often pay less per hour. Compare the total cost and what you have at the end, not the session price. Some employers fund coaching from a development budget, so it is worth asking. If you wonder about tax treatment, that is a question for your accountant.

Before you pay anyone

Questions to ask

Ask any coach, including me, what you will have at the end, what it costs in total, what their own background is and when they would send you elsewhere. Clear answers to those four tell you more than any testimonial page.

Coaching is unregulated in Australia, and CHOICE has noted that anyone can use the title.

  • What will I have when we finish? A decision, a plan, a written rationale? If the answer is vague, the sessions will be too.
  • What is the total cost, and when does it end? Open-ended monthly plans make value hard to judge.
  • What have you done outside coaching? Someone who has led people, made hard calls or changed direction themselves brings more than a framework.
  • When would you tell me coaching is not the right help? A good coach can name the cases quickly: health, legal, financial and recruitment questions.
  • Do you receive anything from anyone you refer me to? You should hear about any referral arrangement before you decide.

How it works here

With me, career coaching starts with a short, free quick chat. If it suits, you book one program: four one-to-one sessions over eight weeks, face to face in Norwest or on screen, plus a workbook and text or voice memos between sessions.

Each session has a job, guided by the five phases of my framework, from Clarity through to Continuum. We name the real question, separate your goals from other people's, weigh the options and plan the move so it holds. All four sessions are finished within ten weeks of starting.

My background is 30 years of policing in NSW, rising to Superintendent, where calls were made on partial information and had to be explained afterwards. I do not write resumes or place people in jobs. If that is what you need, I will say so on the call. The career coaching page sets out what sessions cover.

Not sure it is worth it for you?

Ask me in a quick chat. If coaching is not the right help, you will hear that too.

Book a quick chat

Asked often

Before you book

Can a coach get me a job?

Not directly. A career coach helps you decide what to aim for and why, and can help you prepare for the conversations that follow. Finding vacancies and putting you in front of employers is a recruiter's job. Be wary of any coach who promises a role, because nobody outside the employer controls that.

How many sessions will I need?

With me, the work comes as one program of four sessions over eight weeks, which gives most people the time to land a decision and a plan to carry it. Some people come back later for a second program when the next stage arrives. Be cautious of arrangements with no end point.

What is the difference between a coach and a recruiter?

A recruiter works to fill an employer's vacancy and is usually paid by the employer, so the service is free to you. A coach works for you, on your decision, and is paid by you or your employer. Recruiters are useful once you know what you want. A coach is useful before that.

Portrait of Aimee Templeman
About the authorAimee Templeman is the founder of The Continuum Pathway. She has spent 30 years in policing, has led large teams, and has studied psychology and law. She coaches police officers who are good at holding everything together and want to work out what's next for the person underneath the uniform.

More on work decisions

The Continuum Pathway provides coaching. It isn't counselling, psychology or a crisis service. If you need urgent support, call 000 or Lifeline on 13 11 14.