Skip to content
The ContinuumPathway
Home For police How it works About Insights Contact

Property decisions

Property Coach vs Buyer's Agent vs Investment Adviser

A buyer's agent works for you on one purchase, a licensed investment adviser advises on financial products, and a property coach helps you settle the goal before either starts. Most people who search "do you need a buyers agent" are really asking which of the three they need first.

It is for buyers and investors deciding who to pay, and when. More in my articles on making property decisions.

Aimee Templeman, decision coachBy Aimee Templeman6 min read
A buyer in a mustard jumper typing on a laptop at a timber desk

Three roles people confuse

They answer different questions. A buyer's agent answers "which property, at what price?" A licensed financial adviser answers "how should my money, super and insurance be set up?" A property coach answers "what am I actually trying to achieve, and is this the right move now?"

Some self-styled property advisers are paid by the developer whose stock they show you. So ask: who do you act for, and who pays you?

Acts forLicence behind itUsually paid by
Buyer's agentYou, the purchaser, on one searchReal estate licence, or registration under a licensed agent (NSW)You, as a fixed fee or a percentage
Financial adviserYou, across super, investments and insuranceListed on the Financial Advisers Register, authorised under an AFS licenceYou, by fee; check for any product payments
"Property investment adviser"Depends who is payingNone for the title itselfSometimes the seller or developer
Property coachYou, on the decision rather than a propertyNone for coaching; I hold NSW and QLD real estate licencesYou, directly

What a buyer's agent does

A buyer's agent represents the purchaser. They take your brief, search listed and off-market stock, check the property and its paperwork, negotiate the price, and stay with the purchase to settlement. In NSW they must be licensed and must disclose conflicts and third-party payments.

The NSW Fair Trading guidance on buyer's agents sets the ground rules: a real estate licence, or a certificate of registration while working under a licensed agent, a written agency agreement, and a fixed or percentage fee that is not set by law and can be negotiated. They cannot take a payment for steering you to a selling agent.

A good one earns the fee in the detail. I once watched a buyer's agent pull a client out of a purchase over one paragraph in the strata minutes. The client was furious. Six months later the owners were hit with a remediation levy of over $100,000, and the client rang to say thank you.

Match matters as much as the category. A Brisbane unit specialist is not the person to buy your Hobart family home. Ask how many properties they bought in your target area last year, and which recent sales they would compare. A specialist answers on the spot.

What an investment adviser does

A licensed financial adviser gives personal advice on financial products such as super, shares, managed funds and insurance. Direct property is not a financial product, so the title "property investment adviser" carries no licence of its own. Check who you are dealing with before you rely on them.

As ASIC has explained, real property itself sits outside the financial product rules, although recommending that you buy it through a self-managed super fund is financial product advice and needs a licence.

A genuine financial adviser is the right person when the question involves your super, insurance, or how property sits beside your other assets. Look them up on the Financial Advisers Register, which shows their qualifications and what they are authorised to advise on.

Be wary of "free" property strategy. Moneysmart warns that developers, accountants, lawyers and brokers sometimes refer to each other as a group. Free usually means someone else is paying.

What a property coach does

A property coach helps you make the decision itself: what you want the property to do, what you can carry, what you will not buy, and whether now is the right time. The coach does not choose the property, arrange the loan or give personal financial advice.

I come at this from 30 years of police leadership, where calls were made on incomplete information with a clock running. My real estate licences, NSW and Queensland, mean I know the process from the inside. I use that to coach, not to sell you stock or act as your buyer's agent.

When the order is right, each professional does better work. The sequence I see hold up best:

  1. 1

    Decide what this purchase is for

    Goal, timeframe, limits and exclusions, written down before any listing.

  2. 2

    Confirm the finance

    A mortgage broker sets your real borrowing range and loan structure.

  3. 3

    Search and negotiate

    Yourself, or a buyer's agent working from a clear brief instead of building it on the run.

  4. 4

    Lock in the team

    Conveyancer or solicitor for the contract, accountant for tax, property manager if it will be let.

Which you need

If you know exactly what you want and where, you may need only a good broker and conveyancer. Buying in a market you do not know points to a buyer's agent. Super, SMSF or wider wealth questions need a licensed financial adviser. Unsure what or whether to buy? Start with coaching.

I would not pay for a buyer's agent to buy a home in a suburb you have lived in for twenty years, where you know what local sales really mean and have time to do the work.

The case gets strong when you are buying interstate or out of your depth. One client bought an investment alone: good suburb, smooth settlement. Months later a local property manager mentioned two comparable sales in the same street. They had paid about $35,000 more. Nobody lied. They just did not know what they did not know.

Not sure which professional comes first?

Sorting the order, and the brief they will all work from, is where property decision coaching starts.

Property decision coaching

Coaching is paid for directly; any referral arrangement with another professional is disclosed before you decide.

Asked often

Who does what

General answers to what buyers ask me most about these roles. Your own professionals apply them to you.

Are you an adviser?

No. Coaching is not personal financial advice, and I will not pick a product, a loan or a suburb for you. My NSW and Queensland real estate licences inform how I coach, but I do not act as anyone's buyer's agent or broker. Super, lending and tax questions go to the licensed people who answer them.

Do I need a buyer's agent?

Not always. If you know the local market well, have time and can negotiate calmly, you may manage without one. A buyer's agent earns their fee when you are buying somewhere unfamiliar, short of time, or competing against experienced buyers. Get a clear brief first so their work, and their fee, go further.

Who pays whom?

The vendor pays the selling agent. You pay a buyer's agent, through a fixed fee or a percentage written into the agency agreement. A financial adviser charges you a fee, and should tell you about any other payments. Coaching is paid for by you, up front, with any referral arrangement named before you commit.

Aimee Templeman, founder of The Continuum Pathway
About the authorAimee Templeman is the founder of The Continuum Pathway. She has spent 30 years in policing, has led large teams, and has studied psychology and law. She coaches police officers who are good at holding everything together and want to work out what's next for the person underneath the uniform.

Related reading

Before you hire anyone

Get the order right

The quick chat is free and short, about 15 minutes. Describe the purchase you have in mind and I will say plainly which professional you need next, even if that is not me.

How coaching runs

  • Four sessions over eight weeks, one program
  • In person in Norwest, or online anywhere in Australia

The Continuum Pathway provides coaching. It isn't counselling, psychology or a crisis service. If you need urgent support, call 000 or Lifeline on 13 11 14. General information only. It is not personal financial, legal or tax advice. Speak to a licensed professional about your circumstances.