Skip to content
The ContinuumPathway
Home For police How it works About Insights Contact

Property decisions

The Townhouse Stigma

On a townhouse vs house investment in a new estate, my answer is that the old rule, houses always win, has to be tested against the two actual properties in front of you. Sometimes the house earns its premium. Sometimes the gap buys far less than people assume.

This piece is for investors comparing new builds in growth-area estates. You will find related reading in my articles on property decisions.

Aimee Templeman, decision coachBy Aimee Templeman6 min readUpdated October 2026
New two-storey townhouses rising behind a line of green trees

The stigma, and why it needs testing

The belief that houses beat townhouses formed when a townhouse meant a small strata unit beside a house on a 600 square metre block. In many new estates the land gap has shrunk to a few dozen square metres, so the rule should be checked, not trusted.

I have had this conversation many times. A client is looking at a four-bedroom house and a five-bedroom townhouse. Same developer, same estate, both new. Which makes more sense? Neither of us can say until we model it. What always arrives first is the assumption: "Townhouses don't perform as well, do they?" Ask where that came from and there is usually a pause.

Most of us absorbed it from a relative who bought well in the eighties. Back then it was often right. A house had far more land, land tends to appreciate, and families wanted yards. The market has moved since. The stigma has not.

What new estates changed

In the outer growth corridors I work in, house-and-land lots of 200 to 300 square metres are common, with the house filling the block. Across the laneway sits a townhouse on perhaps 100 to 150 square metres, also with a double garage, built by the same developer under the same covenants. If the house is $650,000 and the townhouse $580,000, ask what the extra $70,000 buys. Often it is a little more land, a wider setback and the word "house" on the contract.

A real comparison from my client work

Same estate, outer west Melbourne4-bed house5-bed townhouse
Price$680,000$660,000
Land263 sqm212 sqm
Rent estimateAbout $570 a weekAbout $510 a week
Gross yield4.36%4.02%
Weekly holding costSimilarSimilar
Likely resale buyersOwner-occupiers and investorsMostly investors

A 2026 client comparison. Rents were agent estimates at the time; gross yield is a year's rent divided by price. Illustration only, not a forecast.

She expected the cheaper townhouse to win on cashflow. Once interest, rent, depreciation, management and tax were modelled together, the holding costs came out close, so the townhouse's case rested on a $20,000 entry saving against less land and a narrower pool of future buyers. The house was the right call. Not because of the stigma. Because of the numbers.

The checks that settled it work for any pair of properties:

  • Yield. A lower price does not mean a higher yield if the rent gap is wide too.
  • Depreciation. New builds can usually claim deductions on the building and its fittings, and a townhouse often carries more building per dollar. Get a schedule for each. At $140,000 of taxable income the marginal rate is 37% in 2025-26 and 2026-27, per the ATO resident tax rates, so each extra dollar claimed is worth about 37 cents.
  • Weekly cashflow. Model it per property at your income. Estimates mislead.
  • Entry price. A $20,000 gap is modest. An $80,000 gap changes the deposit, stamp duty and borrowing.

Both properties here were new builds, which matters more since the 2026 Budget. My piece on what changed for negative gearing and CGT covers that.

I have seen the numbers favour houses and favour townhouses. I have never seen skipping the comparison help anyone.

Coaching: testing the assumption with you

Coaching slows the comparison down so the numbers decide, not the label. I will not tell you which property to buy. I help you set up a fair comparison, work out what to ask your broker and accountant, and notice when a preference is a feeling rather than a finding.

A house can deserve its premium. That is more likely when its land is meaningfully larger in a suburb short on established stock, when local rental data shows tenants prefer standalone homes, when you may live in it one day, or when the townhouse's owners corporation levies would change the cashflow. In Victoria, an owners corporation certificate must be attached to the Section 32 vendor statement where one applies, as Consumer Affairs Victoria explains, so read it before you rely on anyone's verbal answer.

Sometimes "I'd rather own a house" really means "a house feels more successful". That is human, and worth knowing before the contract. Once a property is in view, a mortgage broker can model the real weekly cost. I can suggest brokers I trust; where a referral arrangement exists, I tell you before you decide.

Two properties, one decision?

We build the comparison together, then you choose.

Coaching for investors

Asked often

Townhouse questions, answered

The questions investors raise most when a townhouse is on the shortlist, in general terms.

Do townhouses grow in value as much as houses?

It depends on the market. Where both house and townhouse lots are small, the drivers of growth, such as infrastructure, population and rental demand, apply to both, and land is not a big enough difference to dominate. On large established blocks a house usually holds more land value. Research the specific suburb rather than leaning on a general rule.

Does a Torrens title townhouse have an owners corporation?

Not automatically. A townhouse on its own Torrens title lot does not need one because of the title type. If the estate has shared driveways or common property, though, an owners corporation may still be registered and charge levies. Check the vendor statement and ask your conveyancer before you sign anything.

Will a family rent a townhouse in an outer suburb?

In the growth corridors I have worked in, families often care more about bedrooms, a garage and the commute than about title type, so a large new townhouse can draw the same tenants as a nearby house. Markets differ, so ask two or three local property managers what is leasing quickly before you rely on it.

How do I find out if a townhouse has an owners corporation?

In Victoria, the Section 32 vendor statement is the place to look. Where an owners corporation exists, an owners corporation certificate showing fees and levies must be attached. Have your conveyancer or solicitor review it before you commit, and do not rely on a verbal answer from an agent or developer.

Aimee Templeman, founder of The Continuum Pathway
About the authorAimee Templeman is the founder of The Continuum Pathway. She has spent 30 years in policing, has led large teams, and has studied psychology and law. She coaches police officers who are good at holding everything together and want to work out what's next for the person underneath the uniform.

Related reading

Next step

Let the numbers decide

A free quick chat of about 15 minutes shows whether coaching would help with the choice in front of you.

Handy to bring

  • Both listings or contracts
  • Any rent appraisals you have
  • Your rough income and borrowing figure

The Continuum Pathway provides coaching. It isn't counselling, psychology or a crisis service. If you need urgent support, call 000 or Lifeline on 13 11 14. General information only. It is not personal financial, legal or tax advice. Speak to a licensed professional about your circumstances.