Holding and selling
When to Sell an Investment Property (Decision Framework, Not Advice)
Deciding when to sell investment property comes down to one test: is it still doing the job you bought it for, and can you hold it comfortably while it does? If both answers are yes, a market headline is rarely a good reason to sell. If either is no, the options below are worth weighing properly.
This framework is for owners facing that call now, written in general terms. It sits alongside the other guides to property decisions.
By Aimee Templeman6 min readUpdated October 2026
Sell, hold or refinance: the decision
There are three options, not two. Selling releases capital and ends the holding costs. Holding keeps the asset working toward its original purpose. Refinancing changes the loan rather than the property. Working out when to sell investment property starts with which of those three actually fixes the problem in front of you.
| Option | When it tends to fit | What it costs you |
|---|---|---|
| Sell | The property can no longer do its job, or the capital matters more somewhere else. | Agent's fees, advertising and legal costs, possibly CGT, and the cost of buying back in later. |
| Hold | The purpose still stands and the cash flow is manageable, even if growth has been slow. | Your reserve, your patience, and what the equity might have done elsewhere. |
| Refinance | The property is fine but the loan, rate or repayments are the real problem. | Fees, a fresh credit check and, if you draw equity, more debt. |
Selling costs as listed in Moneysmart's guide to investment property.
Most owners who ask me whether to sell are asking something else underneath. Can I keep carrying these repayments? Do I still want the tenant calls? Should I be doing what my brother-in-law did? Name the real question and the right option usually becomes plain.
Reasons that hold up
Sound reasons to sell are tied to the property's purpose or to your own life: it cannot deliver what you bought it for, holding it is straining your finances, your goals have shifted, or the capital would work harder elsewhere after costs. Each one can be tested against real numbers.
- The purpose has gone. A growth purchase in an area that has stalled for reasons that will not change, or an income property that now costs more than it earns.
- Holding costs are hurting. If you top it up from savings every month with no end in sight, the property is running you.
- Your life has moved. Separation, a new business, a child's needs or retirement planning can make capital more useful than the asset.
- Too many eggs in one basket. Most of your wealth in one property or city is a risk worth reducing.
- Big repairs you cannot fund. A building report pointing to major spending in the next few years, with no reserve to cover it.
Reasons that do not
Weak reasons to sell are mostly reactions: a price headline, one bad tenant, a neighbour's sale, fear of a tax change, or boredom with an asset that is quietly doing its work. They feel urgent in the moment and look thin a year later, once the costs of selling are counted.
- A forecast. Nobody calls the top of a market reliably.
- One difficult tenancy. A better property manager often fixes this for far less than the cost of a sale.
- Racing the 2027 tax change. According to Treasury, the new CGT rules apply to gains that accrue from 1 July 2027, so growth before that date keeps the 50% discount. Check your own position with an accountant before acting on a deadline.
- A call from an agent. "Buyers are waiting for homes like yours" is marketing, not information.
There is also a reason to pause. If you bought before 7.30pm on 12 May 2026, the property is grandfathered and keeps its current negative gearing treatment. Swap it for an established home and the new one loses wage offsets from 1 July 2027. And if it is tenanted in NSW, selling is an accepted reason to end the lease, but the NSW minimum notice is 90 days on a periodic agreement while the sale is only proposed, and 30 days once a contract requires vacant possession.
The questions for your accountant
Your accountant should run the tax numbers before you list, not after you sign. Take these questions with the purchase contract, records of costs and improvements, and the depreciation schedule, so the answer is about your property rather than a general rule read online.
- What would my capital gain be if I sold this financial year, and next year?
- How is the gain split around 1 July 2027, and do I need a valuation as at that date?
- Does the contract date or the settlement date decide which year the gain falls in?
- What happens to any losses I have been carrying forward?
- How does selling this one change the treatment of what I own or buy next?
I do not give tax advice, and neither should anyone who earns a commission when you sell. These questions get you a straight answer from someone qualified to give it.
Coaching the next move
Coaching helps when the numbers are clear but the decision still is not. I help you separate the property question from the life question underneath it, test each option against your goals, and leave with a choice you can explain and a plan for what comes after.
A sale is rarely the end of the story. Decide where the money goes, whether debt, another purchase, a business or time, before you list, so the proceeds do not drift toward whatever is easiest. A program is four sessions over eight weeks, online or in Norwest, and the decision stays with you throughout.
Investor coaching puts the whole portfolio, and your plans, on the table first.
Asked often
Before you list
Short, general answers. Your accountant and broker will work from your actual figures.

Should I sell my investment property now?
Only you can decide, ideally with your accountant and broker beside you. Test it this way: is the property still doing the job you bought it for, and can you hold it without strain? If both answers are yes, a market headline is a weak reason. If either is no, compare selling and refinancing side by side.
What about tax when I sell an investment property?
A sale usually triggers capital gains tax on any gain. Under the Tax Reform No. 1 Act, gains accruing from 1 July 2027 lose the 50% discount and move to cost base indexation with a 30% minimum tax, while growth before that date keeps the discount. Ask your accountant to model your own numbers.
How do I know it is time to sell?
It is usually time when the reason concerns the property's purpose or your life, not the market. Signs include holding costs you cannot sustain, a goal that has changed, a property that cannot deliver what you bought it for, or capital you need elsewhere. Write the reason down, then check it again a month later.
Sell, hold or refinance
Decide before you list
Fifteen minutes, no charge: tell me what is pulling you toward a sale and I will be straight with you about whether a program makes sense yet.
Useful to bring
- Why you bought the property
- What has changed since
- Any appraisal you have been given
The Continuum Pathway provides coaching. It isn't counselling, psychology or a crisis service. If you need urgent support, call 000 or Lifeline on 13 11 14. General information only. It is not personal financial, legal or tax advice. Speak to a licensed professional about your circumstances.