Skip to content
The ContinuumPathway
Home For police How it works About Insights Contact

Investing

How to Buy an Investment Property: The Decision Sequence

How to buy an investment property, in one line: decide what the property has to do for you before you decide which property it is. The buying steps, from pre-approval to settlement, are well documented. The decisions that sit in front of them are not, and that is where the expensive mistakes tend to start.

This guide is for first-time investors and for owners planning the next purchase who want an order to work in. It follows the five phases I use with clients, from knowing where you stand to the review you do once the tenant is in. Every figure has a named source, and none of it is personal advice. There is more in my property decision guides.

Aimee Templeman, decision coachBy Aimee Templeman11 min readTax rules checked October 2026
Dark stepping stones laid in sequence across a gravel garden path

Buying is a sequence, not an event

Buying an investment property is five decisions made in order: where you stand, what the property is for, which property and on what terms, how you will hold it, and when you will review it. Skip one and the next gets made on a guess.

Most articles on how to buy an investment property start at pre-approval and finish at settlement. What they rarely cover is the thinking that should happen before a lender sees your payslips, and the discipline needed after the keys change hands.

In policing I learned that the order of decisions matters as much as the decisions themselves. Commit people and equipment before you understand the situation and you spend the rest of the operation correcting it. Property behaves the same way. Buyers who choose the suburb first and the strategy second often spend years bending the strategy to fit the suburb.

  1. 1

    Clarity: know your position

    Savings, debts, income, a borrowing ceiling you choose yourself and a cash reserve.

  2. 2

    Direction: give the property a job

    Growth, income or a mix, over a stated timeframe, plus what you will not buy.

  3. 3

    Decision: choose on evidence

    Checks finished, contract reviewed and a walk-away price written down before you bid.

  4. 4

    Stability: hold it well

    Manager, insurance, records and a reserve, so the first bad month does not shake you.

  5. 5

    Continuum: review and choose what is next

    Hold, improve, refinance, sell or buy again, decided on purpose each year.

Each phase has its own section below, with the questions I ask clients at that point. The five-phase framework explains where the phases come from and how they work for career and life decisions too.

Clarity: know where you stand

Clarity means knowing your real position before you open a listings app: savings, debts, how stable your income is, what a lender will offer and what you are prepared to borrow. The lender's figure is a ceiling, not a target. The gap between the two is your safety margin.

3 ptsAdded to your rate when a lender tests repayments (APRA)
80%Borrow above this share of the value and LMI usually applies (Moneysmart)

Lenders test an investment loan as if the rate were three percentage points higher than the one you will pay, a buffer APRA kept at that level in July 2025. That protects the bank. It does not tell you whether the repayments still work when the property sits empty for six weeks, or when you change jobs.

Most investors aim for a 20% deposit, because lending above 80% of the value usually brings lenders mortgage insurance, a cost that covers the lender rather than you. On a $650,000 purchase, 20% is $130,000. Stamp duty, conveyancing, searches and a pest and building report come on top, all listed as buying costs in Moneysmart's guide to buying an investment property. The 5% Deposit Scheme will not help here; it requires you to live in the home.

Then the reserve. I like to see around six months of the property's costs set aside before anyone signs: repayments, rates, insurance, strata and an allowance for repairs. It is the difference between riding out a vacancy and selling at the wrong time.

Three questions to answer in writing at this point:

  • What is my income likely to look like over the next five years, honestly?
  • If repayments rose by a few hundred dollars a month, what would I cut first?
  • Who else depends on this money, and do they know the plan?

Direction: decide what the property is for

Direction is deciding the job the property has to do: long-term growth, rent that covers more of its costs, or a blend, over a stated number of years. Once the job is clear, location, property type and price range narrow on their own, and most listings stop being relevant.

"Build wealth" is not a direction. "Hold for fifteen years and own an asset that helps make full-time work optional" is one. A growth property and a high-yield property usually sit in different markets, at different prices, with different holding costs. Asking one purchase to deliver both at full strength is a common way to end up with a property that does neither well.

Direction also covers what you will rule out. I ask every investor for an exclusions list: property types, locations or deal structures they will not consider, each with a reason. Mine was shaped by my own portfolio, the purchases that worked and the ones that taught me something.

Tax now belongs in this phase too. Under the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 1) Act 2026, which received Royal Assent on 26 June 2026, an established home purchased after 7.30pm on 12 May 2026 can no longer offset its losses against your wages from 1 July 2027; those losses only count against residential property income and gains. New builds keep negative gearing. Gains that build up from 1 July 2027 also lose the 50% CGT discount, replaced by cost base indexation and a 30% minimum tax, although new-build investors can choose the old discount. Treasury's summary sets out the detail.

If an established property only works because of the deduction, the plan needs another look before the purchase does.

Decision: choose on evidence

Decision is where you choose a specific property and the terms you will accept, based on checks rather than feel. Write your walk-away price down before you inspect, finish every report and contract review before you are bound, and treat urgency from the selling side as information, not instruction.

The checkWho does it, and what to ask
FinanceYour broker or lender. Formal approval for this property, not only pre-approval, and the repayment once any interest-only period ends.
Building and pestA licensed inspector. Defects now, and which items will need money in the first five years.
Contract and titleA conveyancer or solicitor. Special conditions, easements, the settlement date and, for strata, the scheme's records.
RentA local property manager with nothing to gain from the sale. A realistic weekly rent and how long similar homes sit vacant.
Ownership and taxYour accountant. Whose name the property goes in, and how the 2026 changes treat this particular purchase.

Cooling-off rights depend on the state. NSW Fair Trading sets five business days after exchange for a private sale in NSW, with a 0.25% penalty if you pull out, and no cooling-off period for auction purchases. If you are bidding, every row in that table must be finished first.

This is also the phase where people get hurried. My son was 24 when he came close to signing for a regional Victorian property that had been presented with very confident numbers. Once we looked properly, the distance alone would have made it a headache to run, and the expected return did not survive scrutiny. I pulled the contract before it went further. The checks above would have shown the same thing, if someone had made time for them.

Stability: hold it well

Stability is the first year after settlement: choosing a property manager, landlord insurance, a depreciation schedule, a separate account for the property's money and a cash reserve. Set these up properly and the investment runs quietly in the background. Skip them and small problems keep landing on your phone.

  • Property manager. Choose on how they select tenants and handle maintenance, not on the lowest fee.
  • Landlord insurance. It sits alongside building insurance, and Moneysmart lists both as ongoing costs of owning.
  • Depreciation schedule. A quantity surveyor's report supports claims for the building and its fittings; the ATO explains capital works deductions.
  • A separate account. Rent in, costs out, so you and your accountant can see the true position at a glance.
  • The interest-only end date. Put it in the diary now. Repayments rise when that period finishes.

Stability is emotional as well as practical. The first vacancy or a large repair bill can make a sound purchase feel like a mistake. Decide now what would actually make you sell, so a bad month does not make that call for you.

Continuum: review, then decide what is next

Continuum is a planned review, usually once a year, where you test the property against the job you gave it in the Direction phase. The result is a decision: hold as is, improve, refinance, sell or buy again. Changing nothing is a perfectly good outcome when it is chosen rather than drifted into.

Bring last year's numbers, rent, vacancy, repairs, loan balance and a fresh value estimate, then ask the original question again. Is this property still doing the job I bought it for, and is that still the job I need done?

Growth in equity often prompts the next purchase. That can be the right move, but the sequence restarts at Clarity, not at a listing. If the review points the other way, my guide on when selling an investment property makes sense sets out the reasons that hold up and the ones that do not.

One timing point. A property you already owned before 12 May 2026 keeps its existing negative gearing treatment. Sell it and buy an established replacement, and the replacement falls under the new rules. Ask your accountant to run both versions before you list anything.

Coaching the sequence

Coaching gives the sequence a structure and an outside eye. I work through each phase with you, ask the questions a friend or a salesperson would skip, and hold the timeline so the purchase follows the plan rather than the other way round. Every decision stays yours.

A program is four sessions over eight weeks, in person in Norwest or online, with a workbook and text or voice memos between sessions. With investors, the first two sessions usually go on Clarity and Direction, because that is where the brief gets written. The later sessions cover the shortlist, the checks and how you will hold what you buy.

I am not a buyer's agent, mortgage broker or financial adviser, and I do not sell property to clients. Your broker, conveyancer and accountant do the licensed work. My part is making sure the decision they are helping you carry out is one you have actually made.

Want an outside eye on your plan?

Property decision coaching takes you through these five phases before you commit to anything.

See property coaching

Before you start

Three questions investors ask first

General answers. A broker, conveyancer and accountant will work from your actual numbers.

How long does it take to buy an investment property?

The visible part, from an accepted offer to settlement, is set by your contract and your state's rules. The groundwork takes longer. In my experience, getting clear on your numbers, writing the brief and building a shortlist can reasonably take two or three months. Rushing that stage to keep up with a market is where most regret begins.

Do I need a buyer's agent to buy an investment property?

No, though some investors find one useful, particularly when buying interstate or in a market they cannot inspect in person. A buyer's agent searches and negotiates for you and is paid to complete a purchase. Settle your brief and walk-away price first, so the agent works to your strategy, and ask exactly how they are paid before you sign.

When should I involve a mortgage broker?

Early, during the Clarity phase and before you look at listings. A broker can show you what lenders will offer, how the three percentage point buffer affects your borrowing and which loan structure suits an investment. Get pre-approval before you search, then return for formal approval on the specific property before any contract binds you.

Aimee Templeman, founder of The Continuum Pathway
About the authorAimee Templeman is the founder of The Continuum Pathway. She has spent 30 years in policing, has led large teams, and has studied psychology and law. She coaches police officers who are good at holding everything together and want to work out what's next for the person underneath the uniform.

Before the first inspection

Write the brief first

The free quick chat takes about fifteen minutes. Tell me which phase you have reached and we can both judge whether coaching would add anything or you are ready to carry on alone.

Handy to have

  • A rough list of savings and debts
  • Any pre-approval you already hold
  • The property or deal you have been shown, if any

The Continuum Pathway provides coaching. It isn't counselling, psychology or a crisis service. If you need urgent support, call 000 or Lifeline on 13 11 14. General information only. It is not personal financial, legal or tax advice. Speak to a licensed professional about your circumstances.